When Children Are Being Rude

My daughter is eating something and starts to feel thirsty. She gets up from where she is sitting, makes her way to the fridge, opens it and looks inside before exclaiming exasperatedly “ugh where is my water, why isn’t my water here?”.

She scans the kitchen and sees it sitting on the bench next to the water filter; I had gathered them all there intending to fill them and got distracted by something else so hadn’t yet.

“Muuuuuuum” she calls as I’m starting to make my way over “you haven’t filled my water, you need to fill my water NOW”.

Things inside me start to bristle. I start telling myself… I mean it’s pretty nice that I (generally) keep their water filled for them at all. And half the time I even have to search out the water bottles to do so. And surely she could be a little understanding that I hadn’t got to it yet today considering how many things I have to do. And she definitely knows if she asks for help, I am always willing to help so she doesn’t need to be so RUDE.

Let’s pause this scenario to assess.

The way she has spoken to me has instantly got me on the defensive. I’m feeling hurt, I’m feeling unappreciated, I’m feeling a bit of guilt that I had actually completely forgotten to fill them. And my internal dialogue is feeding off of those feelings, trying to justify them to comfort me from all of those uncomfortable feelings. And the most tempting next action in that moment is? Releasing it; spewing all of that out at her, essentially being rude back.

But let’s circle back to the first realisation: the way she has spoken to me has instantly got me on the defensive. And as I’ve seen by where my brain takes me next, that is not very conducive of finding a resolution — it just continues the cycle of conflict.

In these moments, it is very easy to lose sight of our intention and to begin thinking that ending a conflict comes from one person asserting their “rightness”; from somebody winning. And well, geez, that better be me hey? And your brain starts sending you all the justification, it starts amping you up to win, it’s cheering you on and completely ignoring the existence of other person.

Because when we start down that path, if we have to acknowledge that for this to occur we must condemn our children to be our adversary then that’s going to really put a damper on our hype. Because if we are right, then our children must be wrong. And if we win, then they must lose. Which hopefully doesn’t actually sound all that appealing.

We have such a resistance to forgiveness. Forgiveness isn’t always the act of accepting a physical apology, it is in essence affording somebody grace in their missteps. Which is really what this comes down to; if I react in aggression (passive or active) then I am opposing forgiveness, I am opposing understanding. We see forgiveness as weak, as surrendering; essentially as losing. But how does holding onto your hurt and projecting that back onto somebody else really improve your sense of self, your connection with them, your life?

What if forgiveness, which is an investment in our connection, which is an investment beyond the mistakes to what is happening now, which is an acknowledgement of our shared humanity (we all make mistakes), is actually strength? Surrendering to joy? Everybody “winning”?

So really, perhaps, what we actually want is to get back on the same side so that we can see and hear each other (empathy: we are navigating this together) rather than only ourselves (defence: I need to look out for me).

Sure, objectively, what my daughter said was pretty rude. But subjectively? It’s not that difficult to understand. I’ve been her, we have all been her.

And if somebody wins at the expense of the other person, that is not the cycle ending; that is the end of that battle perhaps but it is an investment in a continual war. For the cycle to actually end, you need to stop fighting. You need to invest in peace.

Let’s go back to that moment, a legitimate moment that happened just yesterday. We have my daughter, indignantly demanding water and me, standing there preparing to respond.

And let’s choose understanding. Kindness. Forgiveness. Empathy. Let’s invest in peace.

“Oh wow you must be thirsty, I completely forgot to fill it, I will do it right away”.

And you know what happened?

My daughter saw me. I had shown myself to her; understanding, kind, forgiving, helpful, ally. Because that’s what our response is; a showing of self. If I had reacted in anger they would not have seen their own choices even if that was the words I was speaking. They would have seen me; anger, spite, adversary and I’m almost certain that they would have reacted in kind.

But my daughter saw me and she moved towards me, figuratively and literally. She reached out and hugged me and she said “thank you, I love you”. And this moment felt more than the water because really, it is always more than the water.

You might wonder is that not just reinforcing rudeness by reacting with kindness? I suppose, if you believe that rudeness is inherently a valuable choice but do people want to be rude?

Where does rudeness actually come from? An unmet need AND a fear that that need will remain unmet; desperation. The thing that counteracts rudeness when we recognise it in this way is security. And the thing that breeds security is connection.

What was her reaction to my kindness? Did rudeness continue? Or did she reciprocate my bid to connect?

A defensive cycle begins when we feel somebody is showing us their interpretation of us and we don’t like what we see; we think “oh that’s me? You think I’m so bad? Well, let me show you, you” as a way of diluting and dismissing the image. Of course, when we see it in this light, it seems clearer that the best way to connect to the intention of us is make choices that align with that reality.

But wait explaining “I fill this everyday” is about us, not our children? But we make words about us and a child hears; “you’re ungrateful of all that I do”. And surely our child demanding water isn’t about us? But we make the words about us and we hear; “you should have already filled this, you’re failing to keep your child hydrated”. Even if that is not the motivation behind the words, other’s assertions feed the security or insecurity already within us.

Every moment in your life is an invitation to show yourself. Defensiveness can feel like “teaching somebody a lesson” but it really is actually an attempt to hide ourselves; to say “oh don’t look at me, look at you” and well, still showing ourselves in the process. If you don’t actively and intentionally show YOU, your ‘you’ will show through the filter of your insecurities and fears and pain. If you don’t actively and intentionally show YOU, how will your children ever feel capable of showing themselves?

You cannot connect to an illusion, you cannot connect to a barrier. And the origin of so much of our hurt is disconnection. How can we be invested in another person; their thoughts and feelings and needs, without connection to them? And how can we be connected to them without connection to ourselves?

In reality, this applies to our relationships with our children but also with everyone; our partners, our relatives, our friends and even strangers! And of course, with ourselves; we are often the hardest person to forgive or to show grace to but the most important because it is the seed of our ability to forgive everybody else.

When somebody is projecting at us (whether that looks like rudeness or something else), they don’t need us to correct their image (“you shouldn’t be rude”) or their image of us (“I do so much for you”), they just need us to be us, unconditionally (considerate, grateful, whatever we are inspired by our ideals to be).

They just need us to be us.

You may also like

17 Comments

  1. Thank you. This is a great articulation of why I hate people correcting my child when he is ‘rude’, and also why I struggle to reply in a way that works for both of us. “Affording someone grace in their missteps”. Simply perfect. Shall be sharing.

    1. Grace? Sure. But grace doesn’t mean you don’t correct rude behavior. Grace is understanding that they still have much to learn, are having a bad day, or more. It’s not ignoring the behavior all together.

      1. Did the situation not resolve? Did my daughter not realise her disconnecting words and make a bid to reconnect? What do you actually feel is missing here? Or is it just uncomfortable to think that a child wouldn’t be explicitly “put in their place”?

  2. This is awesome, thankyou for dissecting this. I feel like this knowledge is inside me intuitively but oftentimes I lose touch with it and maybe never had the words to make it explicit. Haha, I’m not sure if that makes sense above but thankyou, I really appreciate being able to read your breakdown of such a small but also enormous interaction.

  3. This has been my favourite of all your posts so far. So refreshing to read the simple truth that we all have such difficulties with, I’m talking world wide, if only every person would read this and learn from it. I sure am working on this daily. Thanks

    1. Oh I so feel similar!! Imagining a world where we assume the best of people and invest in our connection is so inspiring to me. I very enjoyed sharing this message through this post. Thank you for your kind words ❤️

  4. I appreciate your perspective and agree that responding to a rude act defensively or in a rude manor does not teach our children by example. However, I do believe our children can easily become too “entitled” to our never ending mom services and will not learn to appreciate them if we neglect to call out their rude behaviors. I think admitting we forgot and asking for their help shows humility and that we may need some teamwork. My son started bringing in the recycle bins at five years old, when he could not see over them. Why? Because we are a family and we help each other. In this instance, I would have said, “How do you ask?” My son would have changed his tone and added a please. I would say something like, “So sorry, would you mind being a good team player and bringing your water bottle over and help filling it up? I forgot.” This empowers my son to help, shows that I’m human, and that it’s okay to be human and forget. The sooner our children discover that we are human, the sooner we get them off the rude road to entitlement and on the road to kindness and empathy. I have friends who spend two hours in car pool because their kids “get mad” if they have to wait more than five minutes. Really? These kids need to sweat it out on a bus for a while to appreciate their comfy van and juice box that may not be first in line to pick them u..

    1. I don’t see it the same way. I think empathy is best developed from being in touch with ones own emotions (so that we can then explore that feeling genuinely when we see the signs in somebody else), then by somebody telling us how we should feel about how they feel. I see that in my children (I have a daughter older than the one in this story also) and I see the difficulty of empathy in those adults who grew up denied their feelings and supplied feelings by somebody else.

      My daughter is entitled to certain things: care, respect, love, autonomy, freedom of thought etc. That does not cause me resentment when I actually explore where my feelings originate from.

  5. Just yesterday we were driving home from school talking about our days. I recounted the morning traffic jams:accidents that affected my morning drive. My 6 yr old son ipensky said he didn’t know if he really believed me or not. I was hurt & reacted in indignation & stayed hurt for awhile. This message was just what I should have done. He did not mean to imply I was lying, he truly hasn’t been in or seen any accidents let alone multiple or sat in true traffic jams.I knew I handle it poorly because that evening I replied to him in the same way as he had about something & his reaction was hurt & anger – he did as I had done. Parenting is hard, I’m still learning.

  6. This was an interesting article and I’ve definitely taken away from it the message about meeting rudeness with the same. I’m guilty of it for exactly the reasons you outline. However, my second reaction was the same as Lola’s – you don’t need to be rude to get across the message that we are not here to serve. They should be encouraged to do anything they are capable of doing for themselves. For what it’s worth, I also don’t think it’s a bad thing for kids to see that something they’ve said is hurtful or makes us angry. How else do they know we’re human and have the same feelings and reactions they do?

    1. Because they’re in touch with their own emotions, they appreciate those feelings in other people. I could tell from her reaction she knew what she had said was disconnecting, hence her wanting to reassert our connection.

      There is so much conjecture about what children need, we seem to be ignoring who children actually are!

  7. I really appreciate your valuable sharing, it feels right, however I have given kindness when my child is rude many many times and he is still rude….and seems to be rude more often. I’ve also seen this with other parents whose children continue to be rude for there growing years. Isn’t it a boundary issue also? Should one not tell there child that demanding in an unpleasant way is not a kind way to interact with other people? By allowing my child to talk rudely to me am I showing him that I let people abuse me and I don’t have a boundary for unkind behavior? I have recently begun to say in a calm and loving way that I can’t help him when he talks to me in this way. Is this not showing him that kindness attracts kindness more often that rudeness will attract kindness? Isn’t letting him be rude and responding to his demands actually teaching him that it is okay for him to disrespect people?

    1. If rudeness is a continual issue I would look into why. And no, I don’t think it is because a child sees it as the ideal choice based on the adults reaction. Rudeness is a sign of insecurity; what reasons does the child have to feel distrust in their relationships and the meeting of their needs?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *